Where to Find the Best Pizza on Hilton Head Island

Share This Post

Pizza is one of those foods that just works on vacation. Itโ€™s easy to share, great for families, and perfect after a long day at the beach. Hilton Head Island has no shortage of spots to grab a slice or a whole pie, whether youโ€™re in the mood for something classic, casual, or a little more fun. From local favorites to lively hangouts, these are some of the best places to find pizzas on the island during your stay.

Margharita Pizza at Local Pie | Photo by Local Pie

Local Pie

Online Ordering | Take-Out | Delivery | Dine-In
Website | (843) 842-7437
55 New Orleans Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

If youโ€™re looking for perfectly crispy thin-crust pizza made with incredibly fresh ingredients, Local Pie is a solid choice. This Hilton Head Island favorite is known for its wood-fire pizzas, ranging from the classics that keep it simple yet flavorful, to the featured pies that really have some wow-factor. Create your very own pizza creation, or take a gander at the calzone, salad, and starter sections on the menu. Oh, and the dessertsโ€”itโ€™s not easy to pass up their Cookie Skillet or Cannolis!

The Hilton Head Island location is conveniently found on the south end of the island. If you find yourself in Old Town Bluffton, thereโ€™s also a Local Pie located right on State of Mind Street.

Mellow Mushroom

Online Ordering | Take-Out | Delivery | Dine-In
Website | (843) 686-2474
33 Office Park Rd, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Mellow Mushroom is one of those places that works for just about everyone. The vibe is casual and fun, the menu is ginormous, and the pizza is consistently goodโ€”it might even be your favorite pizza joint where you live! Whether youโ€™re sticking with a classic pie or youโ€™re trying one of their specialty options with fun namesโ€”weโ€™re looking at you, Maui Wowie and Holy Shiitakeโ€”your whole group wonโ€™t be disappointed.  And did we mention the menu is huge? Your family and friends will definitely find something up their alley, especially vegan and gluten-free diners.

Giuseppiโ€™s Pizza & Pasta House

Online Ordering | Take-Out | Delivery | Dine-In
Website | (843) 785-4144
50 Shelter Cove Ln, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

The Shelter Cove Towne Centre location is a dependable go-to when youโ€™re either staying on the north end or the middle of the island, and especially if youโ€™re visiting the shops or letting the kiddos run around the community park nearby. The pizza is literally award-winning, and thereโ€™s something for everyone regardless if your either in the thin, thick, or stuffed crust camps. A great spot for a casual lunch or dinner, Giuseppiโ€™s Pizza & Pasta House is a great pick for larger groups or diners who are also big fans of wingsโ€”thank us later!

Mangiamoโ€™s Hilton Head Pizza Co.

Online Ordering | Take-Out | Delivery | Dine-In
Website | (843) 682-2444
2000 Main St, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

This north-end Main Street pizzeria serves up classic pies alongside pasta, wings, and other favorites that make it easy to please a crowd. Mangiamoโ€™s atmosphere is casual and friendly, and itโ€™s a great place to relax and enjoy a slice or two after a beach day or while catching a gameโ€”especially for Buckeye fans. Many locals and visitors alike enjoy the hearty toppings and simple yet satisfying pizzaโ€”nothing too crazy, just good food and good vibes.

The Frosty Frog Cafe

Online Ordering | Take-Out | Dine-In
Website | (843) 686-3764
1 North Forest Beach Dr, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

The Frosty Frog Cafรฉ is one of those places where thereโ€™s always something going on. The inside is fun, colorful, and over-the-top (in the best way possible), often with live music playing, games on the TVs, and frozen drinks at the ready. While most people come here for the daiquiris and the fun atmosphere, itโ€™s also a great place for delicious grub. And while this is the only spot on this list that isnโ€™t strictly a pizza joint, the pizza on the menu is tasty and a great option for the whole table.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Stay up to date with all things Hilton Head!

More To Explore

Uncategorized

Day Trips to Take From Hilton Head Island

Hilton Head Island is known for its pristine beaches, beautiful walking and bike paths, and its laid-back Lowcountry lifestyle, but there is so much more to discover beyond the island

Learn More About

How To Become A VIP Guest

We have all the tips, tricks, and resourcesย  you’ll need to plan your perfect Hilton Head getaway, and our local experts can help you save on all your activities, excursions, dining, lodging, and more.